NOTE: If you haven't read the 'Foregrounding' blog post or the one entitled 'Rough Draft', please do that first. They're both short, but they matter a lot for what you're about to read. Okay. Done.
Enjoy.
Zach de la Rocha: "On truth devoured/Silent play in the shadow of power/A spectacle monopolized/The cameras eyes on choice disguised." Rage Against the Machine's single "Guerilla Radio" from their Battle of Los Angeles album is a reaction against the political circus and faux-choice presentations during the 2000 elections. The quote is not in full context (it is much more political than theoretical) here, but it provides a powerful starting block. A little bit of re-punctuation will help to clarify the thrust: "On truth devoured, silent play in the shadow of power [is] a spectacle [that] monopolized the cameras' eyes-on choice disguised." Line by line, we see parallels between how video games are perceived outside of aficionados, the reason for their strength, and the pitfalls of the game.
On truth devoured
At its most general, truth is subjective, reliant upon the interpreter to understand and decide what is or is not real-and, arguably, what is or is not truth. Tautological, this line of thinking is, in some senses, crystallized by the game. The truth of what the avatar Petitor sees in any game and the truth of what the gamer sees are separate. "There is no spoon," a popular Buddhist axiom, is the reality of reality for Petitor. There is no spoon, just as there is no 'ground' on which he walks, no 'sword' for him to swing, no 'enemy' to kill; the 'truth' of the avatar is simply a copy without a true original-a simulacrum.
But is not the game a reflection of reality? Is not the world of, say, Motocross based upon real life locations? Or any number of sports games that are representatives of the actual franchises? In a word: Yes. And that proves the point. A simulacrum, in one of its many senses of the word, is the idea of a replicated piece without the original being present. This is only achievable if the original is by its own construct outside of its copy; that is, that the analog is, ultimately, incompatible with the digital. There is no real Madden if Madden is real.
Hence is truth devoured, consumed upon its own tautological impulses and paraded in front of the gamer's eyes at 60 frames per second.
Silent play in the shadow of power
Both poetic clauses underscore the basic impulses that propel and compel gamers. The first is silent in metaphor only-anyone who has played Rock Band 2 or been to a party with Dance Dance Revolution on the screen knows that gaming does not necessarily preclude noise. What has become silent in the play is this removal of the gamer away from society and into a new sphere of relationship, one that is simultaneously broader and more confined than the one that it is usurping. This silence is one of significance, not volume. What words mean, always already corrupted by a self-referential cycle, is being oppressed by the spectacle.
It's important to note that the play has a locus: in a shadow of power. This concept will be more tightly detailed in the consideration of Metal Gear Solid 2, but here it has pertinence, too. If we assume that Petitor is conscious, he might realize that he is being controlled by a being perpetually beyond knowing, beyond understanding. In the blurred shadow of the Other side of the screen, the manipulator would be all powerful and always unreachable. The most chilling thing for our self-aware avatar would be that the play that it was being forced to endure was done in silence-and crippling, decisive power.
A spectacle monopolized the cameras eyes
Marxist theorist Guy Debord is best known for his work Spectacle and Society, and defines his meaning of spectacle in many ways. The one most useful here is this one: "The spectacle in general, as the concrete inversion of life, is the autonomous movement of the non-living." It seems as though this quote is written specifically to describe the over saturation of our society with movement that goes nowhere, an unending cycle of consumption until even the truth is devoured. Further, Petitor's autonomous movements-called 'animations' within the industry-are indeed perpetrated by a non-living entity: himself. The camera's eye follows him; the gamer's eyes follow him. Every movement of Petitor's is watched, controlled, responded to. His fate is not his, but instead he is put on as a spectacle, one that monopolizes the cameras in all areas and all movements.
How frustrated can a gamer become when the 'camera is broken'? How difficult is it to complete a game (and the accusatory finger is pointed at you, early-versions-of-Tomb-Raider) in which 'blind fighting' occurs more often than not? 'I can't see what's going on!' shrieks the gamer, knuckles whitening about the controller in frustration. What rage builds when a monopoly is broken?
On choice disguised
My wife and I build a (in my opinion) fun level in LittleBigPlanet using the custom level creator. In it, the little SackPerson must topple a mighty green dragon in order to proceed through the level. As we tested it, I realized that tackling the dragon was superfluous, despite the fact that we had spent a great deal of time (and level space) on its creation. The reason? The bridge on which the dragon lived had no gate at the end. In effect, the dragon guarded an unlocked entrance to a tower, meaning that the gamer could safely and quickly bypass the 'boss fight' and move on sans difficulty.
To force the gamer into battling the green behemoth, we created a gate that could only be unlocked with a key. The key's path to the key was blocked by the foot of the dragon-a gate that is impossible to open unless the gamer defeated the dragon. Choice, here, is disguised; the illusion of being able to bypass the dragon is pushed onto the gamer. In order to succeed, choice-or rather, non-choice-must be disguised as volition.
Spectacles and Fear
Combine all of these analyses together and you'll get the major response to what there is in gaming that terrifies legislators and galvanizes parents to disregard the First Amendment: there is a monopolized spectacle, a fully controlled scene of non-living, autonomous motion, masquerading as meaning, that is drowning the 'real' world. This combo amplifies with each preceding scandal and shocking (though frequently banal) expression within the video game industry, a type of points multiplier that works against the gamer and the industry-another type of simulacrum.
Perhaps the most pointed argument, however, is the assumption that the following quote is inherently wrong, bad, wicked, or frivolous:
"We live in a spectacular society, that is, our whole life is surrounded by an immense accumulation of spectacles. Things that were once directly lived are now lived by proxy. Once an experience is taken out of the real world it becomes a commodity. As a commodity the spectacular is developed to the detriment of the real. It becomes a substitute for experience." -Larry Law
We'll come back to this later, but it is important to note two fundamental things: (1) Our society as a whole is participatory in a spectacular (that is, dependent on spectacles) way of life, a never ending barrage of visual stimuli, raped of meaning by repetition and dilution. To place video games in a special stratum because of its relative newness to our society is flawed and fallacious. (2) The concept of an ideal world represented in the game turns this concept back into itself-a commodity becomes an experience of a would-be ideal world. This inversion is important to keep in mind, for it flies in the face of logic of those who fear games and their power. It is also a crucial way of understanding games and their power.